ReMix: Jurassic Park 'Concerto for Velociraptor'
- Game: Jurassic Park (Sega, 1993, GEN)
- ReMixer(s): Koelsch1
- Composer(s): Sam Powell
- Song(s):
- Posted: 2006-05-08, evaluated by the judges
Koelsch1 has sent in a number of mixes that have really had some very innovative and expressive arrangement ideas coupled, unfortunately, with problematic production elements or arrangement ideas that didn't fit the context quite so well. This particular mix he finally decided to keep revising, based largely on panel feedback, to a point where it'd more likely "break on through to the other side", and his iterative process has indeed paid off. This JP (Gen) mix uses sax in its intro and outro to evoke velociraptors crying... or howling... or whatever it is that velociraptors did. Perhaps they were just voicing disapproval of Sam Neill; it's hard to say. The effect reminds me of some of the very strange and otherworldy woodwind effects that permeate the soundtrack to the X animated feature. The more melodic sax passages remind me of Branford Marsalis' performances on Horner's Sneakers score (truly great soundtrack), if more minor key and menacing. GL gives mixed praise:
"I was ready to NO this, but the sax work is too nice and luckily it's the star role here. The background material while problematic, is sufficient. Now that it has reverb again, it sounds better. Though I would have pushed the strings a bit further back, especially during the solo harp section and the string pizz/spic where they are exposed and very thin sounding."
The sax is definitely the star, and the strings definitely have some consistency issues. There are times when the sax itself is a little late on the beat; whether intentional or not, it does come off as dragging a bit once or twice. But the arrangement itself capitalizes on the live sax admirably, with afforementioned intro and outro effects that do quite a bit to contextualize the piece and put it in a sort of "double-reed wilderness", in addition to the flowing, legato melody. The ReMixer put quite a bit of time and energy into revising this, but there are still some latent issues with the portions that don't lean as heavily, or at all, on the sax. Collaborations might be one way of learning to handle aspects of accompaniment while turning out pieces that are more polished overall, but if he wants to go the solo route, I can admire that, too, since that's the path I've taken to date. The arrangement's dark and inventive and the sax adds quite a bit of life; other elements have some catching up to do, sure, but the former duo is enough to hold down this particular fort.
The sax here is amazing, but that's about it. Nothing much else here that's worth noting. Fairly average mix.
- 42 on January 20, 2009
Overall, a very nice piece that caught my attention immediately after the first time listening to it.
- Martin Penwald on June 2, 2006
Anyway, let me review the mix. This is some very interesting orchestral ambience. It should have been featured in the movie but it was definately worth a listen. The tuba, strings and violas, although not excellent in sample quality, but which that accompany the sax, are excellent sequenced followers and players (as they play off certain lead parts) of the star, the saxophone. We need more mixes like this. Good job, Koelsch!
8/10
- A-RoN on May 20, 2006
I'd really think of this as more ambient or background music than a concerto piece. I say this because aside from the very beginning the music never really reaches out and grabs you ,but regardless; it sounds nice . The whole velociraptor call thing at the beginning is pretty clever, too!
- Broken on May 14, 2006
This feels really empty and limited to me. Like... [i]really[/i] empty. It doesn't even feel like a song. Things are just jumping in and out with no connection either. Where's the beef? I don't get it. I can't take something like this seriously. The 0:31 section started out interesting... then everything just got progressively lacking and directionless, especially around 1:55 and near the end. My favorite section was probably 3:48, I think the raptor call worked there; I guess? Whatever. Send this to OLR. :lol:
- chokst~1.bat on May 11, 2006
Also, considering Forsaken World, I can't really speak on Darangen's behalf but I'm sure the reason on that is because in spite of some improving production work, the interpretation of the theme itself was too conservative to make it onto the site. That also had a very close vote to accompany it, so I understand your grief with that track.
- Rexy on May 9, 2006
The Orichalcon wrote: Don't question the judges, or bad things will happen to you in your sleep.
Yes sir... ^_^
And Taucer, thanks for righting me me on the whole Star Freezes Over thing... I had forgotten that DJP overuled that one.
As for Saxophone breeding... yeah.
- Zipp on May 9, 2006
chthonic wrote: I felt that the jazz style improvisational sax was completely out of place among the contemporary orchestral backing track, and the backing track itself was pretty weak as far as samples and even arrangement go. The raptor communication at the beginning was extremely creative, however, and I will never hesitate to congratulate someone for making it onto the site. Good work, sir. Hope to see more mixes from you, because you sure know how to play sax. :)
I'm the kind of person that likes blending of styles like this, so I'll have to respectfully disagree with you. :]
- Red Shadow on May 9, 2006
Red Tailed Fox wrote: Red Tailed Fox: New mix yaaay
XenonOdyssey22: omg where?
Red Tailed Fox: I am talking about the Koelsch1 thang
XenonOdyssey22: o yeah, I heard that last night
XenonOdyssey22: INSANE
XenonOdyssey22: VELOCIRAPTORS
Red Tailed Fox: BREEDING WITH SAXOPHONES!!!!!
Red Tailed Fox: VELOCIPHONES!
XenonOdyssey22: OMFG!
XenonOdyssey22: TO THE PHOTOSHOP!
Red Tailed Fox: Omg man, please do this, please.
XenonOdyssey22: I would if I had photoshop
Red Tailed Fox: Yeah, me too...
:P
Man, compare this to my works, and mine make you wanna smash your speakers. Koelsch plays some truly amazing sax, whether it is making velociraptor noises or grooving to the beat. I inspire to play my sax as well as he can. Congratulations on making to OCR, Koelsch. You definitely deserve it.
- Xenon Odyssey on May 9, 2006
- chthonic on May 8, 2006
XenonOdyssey22: omg where?
Red Tailed Fox: I am talking about the Koelsch1 thang
XenonOdyssey22: o yeah, I heard that last night
XenonOdyssey22: INSANE
XenonOdyssey22: VELOCIRAPTORS
Red Tailed Fox: BREEDING WITH SAXOPHONES!!!!!
Red Tailed Fox: VELOCIPHONES!
XenonOdyssey22: OMFG!
XenonOdyssey22: TO THE PHOTOSHOP!
Anyways, I just wanna give my second props to the remixer, I still can't find anything really special about the "velociphones" but the interpretation and sax playing grow on me on every listen.
- Mr. Fox on May 8, 2006
- Snooper_1989 on May 8, 2006
Congrats to Koelsch. I still love the sax in this.
- The Orichalcon on May 8, 2006
Zipp wrote: I don't understand how they could accept this and not, for instance, Daragon's Forsaken World, or Taucer's A Star Freezes Over. These things sometimes seem arbitrary.
The judges DID accept SFO. DJP vetoed the YES decision by the judges, not due to arrangement quality, but due to the fact that it incorporated a non-vg sourcetune.
While I do agree the the production is not what it could be on this piece, I think it more than makes up for it with innovation, and with some truly hot sax.
- Geoffrey Taucer on May 8, 2006
Anyways, it is an okay mix, but I don't really see anything all that special about it. Sure, there are some cool licks, and the raptor sounds are nifto, but I think a lot more could have been done with this then was. I'd give it an "incomplete" rating. At the same time, I do like it's improvisational feel, and the sax is pretty good.
- Zipp on May 8, 2006
Content Policy
(Submission
Agreement and Terms of Use)
Page generated Sat, 04 Jul 2009 20:01:07 -0400 in 0.0535 seconds
All compositions, arrangements, images, and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Original content is
copyright OverClocked ReMix, LLC. For information on RSS and JavaScript news feeds, linking to us, etc. please refer to resources for webmasters. Please refer to the Info section of
the site and the FAQ available there for information about the site's
history, features, and policies. Contact David W. Lloyd (djpretzel), webmaster, with
feedback or questions not answered there.

Discussion: Latest 15 comments/reviews; view the